This article you’ll find everything you need be aware of medical liens for North Carolina (also called “Physician’s Liens”) and how subrogation functions.

As I’ve previously mentioned the process of negotiating a settlement to settle the personal injuries or accident is just the first step in obtaining the amount of compensation you’re legally entitled to. There are still many legal pitfalls that you should know about or you could lose the settlement completely, or even worse, being involved in an Federal suit.

You might be thinking about what I’m speaking about… you’ve just concluded your case. Do you not get to keep the cash from the insurance firm?

No and yes.

When you were receiving treatments, it was likely that you were receiving medical expenses. These bills must be paid. Certain of them might have been paid for through your MedPay insurance. Other charges could have been covered by your health insurance plan or Medicare. Others bills might not have been paid in any way.

After you have settled the lawsuit for personal injuries It is crucial to ensure that all medical practitioners and insurance companies are paid back – typically this is done from the settlement funds. There are two kinds of settlements that have to be paid.

The first one is the health insurance provider to pay them back the money they paid you for medical professionals. The second option is to the medical providers, provided they are still owed bills.

Let’s take on each of these problems one a time.

Who is entitled to a reimbursement from your Settlement Proceeds?

While we’ve boiled this down to medical and insurance providers, here’s an exhaustive list of all who may be interested in receiving some of your settlement payout:

  • Unpaid healthcare providers that are able to prove that they have “perfected” the medical liability of their organization. This includes hospitals, doctor’s offices emergency rooms urgent care clinics, specialists as well as medical facilities for testing (MRI, radiographs, etc. ) as well as chiropractic clinics (maybe) and more.
  • Medicare, Medicaid, and the Veteran’s Administration;
  • Insurance for Workers’ Compensation and,
  • Your Health Insurance company, as long as it’s an ERISA plan.

Liens arise in one of two scenarios. The first and most typical scenario is that the person injured was not covered by medical insurance that could cover the medical costs. In this instance they may be able to negotiate with their insurance provider to keep treatment going if they can pay the cost of treatment from the insurance funds. To get the treatment cost back it is necessary that they be able to prove that they have “perfected” their claim or requested you to submit the “assignment to benefits”.

Another scenario is where you have health insurance but you’re covered under the ERISA plan. In this scenario the health insurance you have is entitled to the right to subrogation. This is a fancy legal method of saying they’re entitled to receive a portion of the settlement. If you don’t get any settlement, they aren’t able to do anything other than take you to collection (or claim you’re liable) however, if you get a settlement, they could request that you pay them.

If you don’tcomply, they may take action against them at Federal Court.

How can a Medical Professional Improve their Lien within North Carolina?

In order to collect the full amount of a settlement for personal injuries medical practitioner must ensure that their lien is perfect under North Carolina law. The laws that govern this procedure are N.C.G.S. SSSS 44-49, and 44-50. Be aware that, under N.C.G.S. SS 44-50 A medical professional may not request greater than 50 percent of the gross settlement in reimbursement.

And now, onto the links…

There are two essential requirements for medical professionals to obtain a lien in accordance with SS 44-49. First, they must supply copies of the medical records and invoices in connection with the claim to the plaintiff’s lawyer or attorney on request. Second they must give an official notification of the amount that they are claiming.

If one of these two conditions are not met the medical practitioner hasn’t fully developed their lien, and therefore they are unable to benefit from settlement funds.

Let’s look at an illustration to give you a an comprehension of the way this is implemented in actual practice.

Let’s say you were struck by a driver who was not yours and you went to the hospital’s emergency room for treatment of your injuries. When you checked out the hospital, they did not require payment or provide any insurance. When you hire a lawyer to assist you and assist you, the lawyer will contact the hospital to request the record of the medical information you have as well as bills. The hospital gives these documents to the lawyer at no cost, and also an official statement in writing stating the amount they claim as a lien for medical reasons on your settlement. Because the hospital didn’t charge you for medical records, and stated the amount of their lien in writing They have perfected their lien, and are now able to claim compensation from your settlement.

But what happens if, following the same scenario that the hospital turned over medical records to your attorney , along with the amount of $50 to cover copies of the documents? Also, let’s assume that they didn’t send an explicit statement in writing of the amount they’re declaring as an obligation. In this scenario it is unlikely that the hospital would have made a perfect lien and wouldn’t be able to claim compensation from the settlement since they not only charged you attorney fees for cost of your medical records, but did not provide an official demand in writing regarding the value of their lien.

But that’s not an end to tale since the medical professional might have requested you to submit the “assignment of benefit”.

The Medical Professional Could also request an Assignment of Benefits

If you believe that you aren’t required to reimburse a health professional back due to the fact that they failed to complete their lien, reconsider your position. Many medical providers will ask that you sign a form known as”assignment of benefits” or “assignment of benefit” prior to starting treatment. It is possible that you have signed this and never thought about that it was. It is a contract that basically states that you’ll instruct anyone who is responsible in handling your settlement funds to pay your medical professional what they owe them from the settlement funds, and if they do not do so, it is a breach of contract , and you’ll be responsible for any debt you are owed by them.

It’s a bit like a medical loan, isn’t it?

However, in this case , it’s from a contract and not from the North Carolina Statutes. However, don’t worry as it is not a problem, as the North Carolina courts have held that the assignment of benefits contract can be considered to be on an equal to medical lien, meaning the provider won’t be able to claim more than they could have if they had developed their lien.

Can You Health Insurance Plan Inquire about Reimbursement?

If you’re hurt in an auto crash and you are covered by health insurance, it’s perfectly normal for you to give the health insurance plan card you have to your doctor to be billed for the treatment. The health insurance plan you have might be able to request compensation from settlement proceeds and others aren’t allowed to making such a request. Determining whether you have to repay your health insurance is a confusing and complex process. You may require the help of an attorney for personal injuries to help you with this.

North Carolina strictly prohibits privately insured medical insurance providers from including subrogation provisions on their policy documents. This means that if you have a health insurance is a privately funded one you cannot ask for reimbursement for payments made to you for treatment.

But that’s not all that’s left of the tale. There’s an exception that allows specific health care plans to request subrogation, regardless of the law of the state that regulates the subject. The exception is only for health plans that are covered by an Federal Law known as the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, also known as “ERISA”.

ERISA Health Insurance Plans Can Invoke Subrogation

In the event that your insurance policy is one that is an ERISA self-funded plan instead of private health plans that is governed under North Carolina law, then it won’t have to adhere to the state legislation that is in North Carolina that prohibits subrogation words in the insurance contract’s language.

The reason behind this is because the ERISA self-funded health insurance plan is subject to Federal Law, not state law. Thus, an employer who offers the ERISA health plan could request reimbursement for medical expenses incurred for the benefit of an employee who was injured in an accident involving a vehicle.

It is a complex legal area, and we highly suggest that you get the advice of a knowledgeable personal injury lawyer prior to agreeing to settle your claim.

Medicaid Liens

Medicaid is a federally funded program administered by states. To be eligible for Medicaid applicants must meet strict limit on assets and income. If you’re covered by Medicaid and are using that program to pay for medical expenses or treatment, then Medicaid will be able to claim an obligation on the amount that they pay for you. That means Medicaid can recover from the amount is paid as settlement or judgment in your case.

But, Medicaid is not able to recover more than 1/3 of your settlement. You can also ask the court to limit the amount Medicaid could recover.

If you’re injured and are relying on Medicaid to cover your medical expenses It is strongly advised that you seek the assistance from a personal injury attorney to assist you in negotiating the terms of your Medicaid lien.

Medicare Liens

Medicare is an Federal Program that is used to provide health insurance to the disabled and elderly. Medicare is considered to be a “secondary payor” which means they won’t pay for your medical treatment until the other options for payment are exhausted.

You should be extremely cautious when Medicare has paid for a part of your medical treatment and is a lien on the settlement as Medicare is the primary lien over any other lien which may be present. In the event of not paying back Medicare will have serious financial consequences, such as having to pay back twice the amount owed. Yikes.

Go back to Claims for Personal Injuries Guide