Arizona Personal Injury Law And Negligence Per Se
- By Chris Zachar
- Published 06/29/2011
- National, State, Local
- Unrated
Negligence per se means that the person who violated the law is automatically deemed to be negligent. More formally, negligence per se applies if someone (1) violates a statute, and (2) causes harm to a person who was (3) within the group of people intended to be protected by the statute, and (4) the harm was the sort of harm the statute was created to prevent. If any one of these four (4) elements is absent, the person who violated the statute is not negligent per se, though they may still be negligent.
In nearly every Arizona personal injury case, it is necessary for an injured person (the plaintiff) to prove that the person responsible for their injuries (the defendant) acted unreasonably. If the plaintiff can establish the four elements of negligence per se, however, the law assumes that the defendant was negligent.
Example: Consider two hypothetical Arizona personal injury cases.
Case #1: A
Case #2: A rental car agency rents a car to a driver whom the agency knows does not have a driver's license, in violation of a state statute. That driver later drives drunk and injures a third party. In a lawsuit by the third party against the rental agency, the court would probably rule that the agency was not negligent per se. Although they did violate the law (element 1) and, at least debatably, cause harm (element 2), it's unlikely the victim can prove elements 3 and 4. The purpose of the statute prohibiting renting a car to someone without a valid license was to keep unlicensed drivers off the road, not to ensure that people driving stayed sober behind the wheel. Of course, it might still be that the agency was unreasonable in renting a car to someone they knew had no license to drive, in which case the victim might prevail.
It is crucial to understand that under Arizona personal injury law, what constitutes "negligence per se' is very particular. It is important to have the guidance of an experienced Arizona personal injury lawyer, to assure that you get the compensation you deserve.
Chris Zachar
Since 1996, Personal Injury Lawyer, Christopher J. Zachar, has provided legal experience to his clients. As an experienced litigator, Chris Zachar has earned a respected reputation among his peers for the favorable settlements and verdicts obtained for injured clients. With distinction among other law firms, Christopher Zachar obtains many referrals from other firms that put their trust in him and his successful track record.
View all articles by Chris Zachar